Gauging interest in a TOM club - Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum

No, but it is a good idea. 2 40.00%

No, and I think it is a bad idea. 0 0%

Hey guys,

A lot of us had decent rep and trader feedback going on at the other site. I thought a fun way to build rep and trader feedback as well as an opportunity to get some good reviews going would be a Tobacco of the Month Club.

I was thinking something along the lines of getting twelve (or even 24) members to commit. Then we would run a poll on either a bunch of baccys or maybe a category of baccy (vaper/virginia/english/etc). Assign one to each month and have each participant sign up for a month.

On your month, you would be responsible for distributing the baccy to the other members. I think if we have twelve participants, that would require about two tins to cover your month (100g or 4 oz total).

Part of the participation would also be posting a brief review of the baccy received by the end of the month.

Anyone interested in getting something like this going? I would be willing to facilitate the signups and keep everything organized.

Maybe criteria for participation should be 2 or more trader feedback here or have good rep/feedback at Puff?

If there is interest in this, I will get a little more coherent set of participation guidelines.

Suggestions also appreciated. :-)

-Tyler
[Reply]

Just thought I should prob mention that I came from Puff and have 11 trader feedback and 400 posts. The CA guys don't know me yet, but I look forward to getting to know ya'll.
[Reply]

I started a monthly tobacco shakedown which is along the same lines as this. If you want to merge that in with this that would be great, if there is enough interest.
[Reply]

OH!!!!! T.O.M.

I thought you were talking about...
Image

...Tom. I WOULD be a member of the Tom (icehog3) club :-):-):-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by Nick:
I started a monthly tobacco shakedown which is along the same lines as this. If you want to merge that in with this that would be great, if there is enough interest.

Sweet, I'll check out the thread. :-)
[Reply]

Originally Posted by md4958:
OH!!!!! T.O.M.

I thought you were talking about...
Image

...Tom. I WOULD be a member of the Tom (icehog3) club

:-)

If you want a Tom club, I would be in, but you have to start it. :-)
[Reply]

Please see Nick's thread here for an ongoing discussion of this topic.

Great minds think alike!
[Reply]

The only difference is that in mind you are responsible for getting your own baccy and it simply promotes more reviews of tobacco for people to read. Let me know what your plans are so we can figure something out.
[Reply]